View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0000980FS Upgrade Project (Media VPs)Model Relatedpublic2013-12-03 22:28
ReporterniffiwanAssigned ToMjnMixael 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityalways
Status resolvedResolutionfixed 
Product Version 
Target VersionFixed in Version 
Summary0000980: some models insignia specify an invalid LOD
DescriptionWhile running some tests with extra debug code added, I noticed that some models insignia are specified to be used in LOD -1. This should not cause any crashes, but the relevant insignia will not show up as expected. I guess they should either be removed, or set for LOD 1?

(I tried using pcs2 to change the insignia for artemis.pof, but the saved file changed far too much from the original for me to be comfortable with making the change myself - never used pcs2 before...)

Models are:
Osiris.pof
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 4 num_verts: 8

artemis.pof
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4

artemisDH.pof
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4

Medusa.pof
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 2 num_verts: 4

Astaroth.pof
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 4 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: 0 num_faces: 4 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 4 num_verts: 4
modelread: ID_INSG: detail_lvl: -1 num_faces: 4 num_verts: 4
(why does this Shivan ship even specify an insignia! :))
Steps To ReproduceFor the models that my version of pcs2 could load,
Additional InformationI checked all the ships in the techroom, these are the only ones I found with this issue. And, I'm probably going to commit some FSO code to warn when the LOD is invalid, just to make it easier to catch this in future.
TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

MjnMixael

2013-12-03 22:28

manager   ~0001206

Fixed in revision 1416

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2013-12-03 04:29 niffiwan New Issue
2013-12-03 22:28 MjnMixael Note Added: 0001206
2013-12-03 22:28 MjnMixael Status new => resolved
2013-12-03 22:28 MjnMixael Resolution open => fixed
2013-12-03 22:28 MjnMixael Assigned To => MjnMixael